ࡱ> hkggqbjbj^^7t< j< j?????SSSSTS1vvv!#P9?vvvvv??v??vg X01$2N$4$?$xvvvvvvvpvvv1vvvv$vvvvvvvvv{ : REVIEW of the official reviewer for dissertation work ___________________________(FULL NAME) on the theme ___________________________________ presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in the specialty __________________. !CriteriaEligibility (one of the options must be checked)Justification of the position of the official reviewer1.The topic of the thesis (as of the date of its approval) corresponds to the directions of development of science and/or state programs1.1 Compliance with priority areas of science development or government programs: 1) The thesis was completed within the framework of a project or target program financed from the state budget (indicate the name and number of the project or program) 2) The thesis was completed within the framework of another state program (indicate the name of the program) 3) The dissertation corresponds to the priority direction of the development of science, approved by the Higher Scientific and Technical Commission under the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan (indicate the direction)2.Importance for scienceThe work makes/does not make a significant contribution to science, and its importance is well disclosed/not disclosed3.The principle of independenceSelf-reliance level: 1) High; 2) Medium; 3) Low; 4) No independence4.The principle of inner unity4.1 Justification of the relevance of the thesis: 1) Justified; 2) Partially justified; 3) Not justified.4.2 The content of the thesis reflects the topic of the thesis: 1) Reflects; 2) Partially reflects; 3) Does not reflect4.3. The purpose and objectives correspond to the topic of the thesis: 1) correspond; 2) partially correspond; 3) do not correspond4.4 All sections and provisions of the thesis are logically interconnected: 1) completely interconnected; 2) the interconnection is partial; 3) there is no interconnection4.5 The new solutions (principles, methods) proposed by the author are reasoned and evaluated in comparison with the known solutions: 1) there is a critical analysis; 2) partial analysis; 3) the analysis does not represent one's own opinions, but quotes from other authors5.Scientific novelty principle5.1 Are the scientific results and provisions new? 1) completely new; 2) partially new (25-75% are new); 3) not new (less than 25% are new)5.2 Are the dissertation findings new? 1) completely new; 2) partially new (25-75% are new); 3) not new (less than 25% are new)5.3 Technical, technological, economic or management decisions are new and reasonable: 1) completely new; 2) partially new (25-75% are new); 3) not new (less than 25% are new)6.The validity of the main findingsAll main conclusions are/are not based on scientifically significant evidence or well-grounded (for qualitative research and areas of training in the arts and humanities)7.The main provisions for the defenseIt is necessary to answer the following questions for each provision separately: 7.1 Is the provition proven? 1) proven; 2) rather proven; 3) rather not proven; 4) not proven 7.2 Is it trivial? 1) yes; 2) no 7.3 Is it new? 1) yes; 2) no 7.4 Application level: 1) narrow; 2) medium; 3) wide 7.5 Is it proven in the article? 1) yes; 2) no8.The principle of reliability Reliability of sources and information provided8.1 Choice of methodology - is justified or the methodology is described in sufficient detail 1) yes; 2) no 8.2 The results of the thesis were obtained using modern methods of scientific research and methods of processing and interpreting data using computer technologies: 1) yes; 2) no8.3 Theoretical conclusions, models, identified relationships and patterns have been proven and confirmed by experimental research (for areas of training in pedagogical sciences, the results have been proven on the basis of a pedagogical experiment): 1) yes; 2) no8.4 Important statements are confirmed / partially confirmed / not confirmed by references to current and reliable scientific literature8.5 Used literature sources are sufficient/not sufficient for a literature review9Practical value principle 9.1 The thesis has theoretical value: 1) yes; 2) no9.2 The thesis is of practical importance and there is a high probability of applying the results obtained in practice: 1) yes; 2) no9.3 Are the practice suggestions new? 1) completely new; 2) partially new (25-75% are new); 3) not new (less than 25% are new)10.The quality of writing and designAcademic writing quality: 1) high; 2) average; 3) below average; 4) low.11.Notes on a thesis12.Scientific level of the doctoral student's articles on the topic of research (in case of defense of the dissertation in the form of a series of articles, the official reviewers comment on the scientific level of each article of the doctoral student on the topic of research)13.Decision of the official reviewer (pursuant to paragraph 28 of the present Model Regulations) In reviews, official reviewers indicate one of the following solutions: 1) to award the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) or Doctor of Specialization; 2) send the thesis for revision (except for cases of thesis defense in the form of a series of articles); 3) refuse to award the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) or Doctor of Specialization. Copies of the reviews of the official reviewers are handed over to the doctoral student no later than 5 (five) working days before the defense of the thesis. Official Reviewer:  DE`aefjkmy{øívhZZøZOZhx5aJmH?sH?hvhv5aJmH?sH?hN@hv>*aJmH sH hN@hN@>*aJmH sH hN@>*aJmH sH hN@hv5>*aJmH sH hN@hv5aJmH sH hv5aJmH?sH?hN@5aJmH sH hN@hN@5aJmH sH hd`h\CJaJ#h\B*CJPJaJmH?phsH?!huAh\B*CJPJaJphD   x $Ifgd} $Ifgd\ $^a$gd\ $^a$gdN@gdZ      v x O P Q R S T U l KLMNQghƼƼvvvƼvfh\h\CJ\aJmH?sH?h}h\CJaJmH sH #h}h\CJKH$\aJmH sH h}h}mH sH h}h\mH sH h}h}CJaJmH sH h}0JmH sH h\h\CJaJmH?sH?h7x#CJaJmH?sH?h\h\5CJaJmH?sH?hvh\5aJmH?sH?' Q R _VMM;dd$@&If[$\$gd\ $Ifgd} $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl\){8  t0844 layt&R S T U l LM^UUUUUU $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl4\){8``  t0844 layt&MNQh^PPB9 $Ifgd\d$Ifgd}d$Ifgd\kdE$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&!-6I_VVVMMMM $Ifgd} $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl\){8  t0844 layt&!-6HIJKNjk+CVWXYZ[_zk`PPhh\CJ\aJmH sH hh\mH sH hh\CJaJmH sH hhCJaJmH sH hY _h0JmH sH h0JmH sH h}h\CJ\aJmH sH h\h\CJ\aJmH?sH?h}h\mH sH h}h\CJaJmH sH h}h}CJaJmH sH h}0JmH sH hY _h}0JmH sH IJKNkVM $Ifgd}kd$$Ifl\){8  t0844 layt& $Ifgd\+CWXUkd&$$Ifl4\){8``  t0844 layt& $Ifgd\ XYZ[^UUUUULU $Ifgd $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&_`3RuAV89[}wmhh0J>* h0Jhh0JmH sH h\hCJaJh\h\CJ\aJmH?sH?hh\CJ\aJmH sH hh\mH sH hh\CJaJmH sH hhCJaJmH sH hh0J>*mH sH h0JmH sH h0JmH sH &3Ru^UUUUULU $Ifgd $Ifgd\kdx$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&AV^UUUULLU $Ifgd $Ifgd\kd!$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&9\]^UUUUUUU $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&[\]^_`=>QRvwǽxkxeWMxhLhL0J>*hLhL0J>*mH sH hL0JhLhL0JmH sH hL0JmH sH hhCJ\aJmH sH hh0J>*hh0J>*mH sH h0Jhh0JmH sH h0JmH sH hh\CJ\aJmH sH hh\mH sH hh\CJaJmH sH h\hCJaJmH?sH?]^_`^UUUUUUU $Ifgd\kds$$Ifl4\){8``  t0844 layt&>Rw^UUUUUUU $Ifgd\kd$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&klmnq#:I\flm}HIƼ՝3՝yyyh 3 0JmH sH h0Jh7x#0JmH sH h7x#0JmH sH h\h\CJ\aJmH?sH?hLhLCJaJmH sH hL0JmH sH h\h\CJaJmH?sH?hLh\mH sH hLh\CJaJmH sH hLhLCJ\aJmH sH .lm^PPB9 $Ifgd\d$IfgdLd$Ifgd\kd$$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&mnq#:I\]TTTTTTTT $Ifgd\kdn$$Ifl\){8  t0844 layt& \fm} $Ifgd\ I_VH???? $Ifgd 3 d$Ifgd\ $Ifgd\kd $$Ifl\){8  t0844 layt&dmrstuvws|ȹpeVpL=h00h00CJaJmH sH h000JmH sH h\h\CJaJmH?sH?h#h\mH sH h#h\CJaJmH sH h#h#CJ\aJmH sH h 3 h\CJ\aJmH sH h 3 h\mH sH h 3 h\CJaJmH sH h 3 h 3 CJaJmH sH h#0JmH sH h\h\CJ\aJh\h\CJ\aJmH?sH? hh\h\h\CJaJdmSE<< $Ifgd#d$Ifgd\kd $$Ifl4\){8``  t0844 layt& $Ifgd\mstuvwsJ<d$Ifgd\kdW $$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt& $Ifgd\ $Ifgd#s|SEEEd$Ifgd\kd $$Ifl4"\){8    t0844 layt& $Ifgd\defgi7@EFGHIJp&9@A;;;擓;擓;׉zzhDhDCJaJmH sH hD0JmH sH h00h\CJ\aJmH sH h\h\CJaJh\h\CJ\aJmH?sH?h00h00CJaJmH sH h000JmH sH h\h\CJaJmH?sH?h00h\mH sH h00h\CJaJmH sH ,efSEE7d$Ifgd00d$Ifgd\kd $$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt& $Ifgd\fgi\SSSSSSS $Ifgd\kd^ $$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&7@FG^UUUUUU $Ifgd\kd $$Ifl4\){8``  t0844 layt&GHIJp^UUUUUUU $Ifgd\kd $$Ifl4\){8    t0844 layt&&9\NNAAAA E$Ifgd\d$Ifgd\kd]$$Ifl4@\){8    t0844 layt&9ABCGYZG99d$Ifgd\kd $$Ifl@\){8  t0844 layt& $Ifgd\ E$Ifgd\ABCFGHXYZ[\_`rstuvyz%dgw:p˴˴vvjvvvv^\UhN@hN@5mH sH hN@B*mH ph333sH hN@hN@B*ph333hDh\CJaJmH sH hDhY _mH sH hDhY _CJaJmH sH hY _0JmH sH h&h&0JmH sH h&0JmH sH h\hY _CJaJmH?sH?hY _CJaJmH?sH?hDh\mH sH hDh\CJaJmH sH #Z[\`stuTFF9 E$Ifgd\d$Ifgd\kd$$Ifl@\){8  t0844 layt& $Ifgd\uvz]OOB9 $Ifgd\ E$Ifgd\d$Ifgd\kdJ$$Ifl@\){8  t0844 layt&%w]TO;;;$-DM `a$gdN@gd\^gd\kd$$Ifl@\){8  t0844 layt&:ppq$-DM `a$gdN@_______________________ _______________________ ________________________ __________________________ (place of work, academic title) (signature) (FULL NAME) ppppp6q?qOqqqqqhN@CJmH sH hN@hN@CJmH sH hN@hvCJmH sH hv 51h0:p\A .!n"n#S$% $$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4" t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4 t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l4@ t08++55 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l@ t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l@ t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l@ t0855 55yt&$$If!vh#v#v #v#v:V l@ t0855 55yt&x666666666vvvvvvvvv666666>6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666hH6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666662 0@P`p2( 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p 0@P`p8XV~ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@66666 OJPJQJ_HmHnHsHtHN`N \1KG=K9$CJOJPJQJ_HaJmHsHtHBA B A=>2=>9 H@8DB 0170F0Xi@X 01KG=0O B01;8F04 l4a .k . 0 5B A?8A:0 \ !5B:0 B01;8FK7:V0 dOJPJQJ^JtHZ^@Z [O01KG=K9 (=B5@=5B)dd[$\$ mH sH tH $o$ }jlqj4b"o!" viiyiPK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭V$theme/theme/theme1.xmlYn7;,XmY2"%MHI#%QI-pN(=4@KEQMѠhWP6}ҊFR ?޼8悰o|m!qP77?*( b\X>&Z!XE?2Y]XmXFKp uK,t8:](rŅb_ n6_I,ZhSPXG'\vzy%!brъ[wa?GC?aZ Q9G֐#@W{mJKLP9'ӧ݆\LbTa Pա_rZXkPi,k^R ~=W- ~R[x ){JT3H-'\,Vj#ѐEڢby؋#7A@ R$IA H& EKP, Ƈ⺏V.ըB:C3.!o =tلEGHq6#LBlhǙȰfEy_) Hu !enhuQ5J+aJhQWz,;&d/B& 2^<] EIj@- <~{^!6cjg^ӊ3'9~:xti 4l2!<SE}]ԢLX)e} rӹfwX2mT.k@hjڒ7e2K…!I'uOD$%QW@cC4|{K i}#N]ܖۍe2|+j˃$냻ak> ĖWʀ"MB>f,Mo0JPhQE1y $2W3A a+P4UMҕr[uR3fZYEUMwv)[^&fV4uO8M Yg\7M6)ƳiXѪ];B^js]YC$YТkPK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!>$theme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] t_[Apq"'+29 R MIX]m\msfG9Zuq !#$%&()*,-./0134568@0(  B S  ?z{NQKN n q  $ giCFHL\_vytvNP $+04KM )8AAPlt6?LU  5 7 M Q s u n p    ! 1 8 ` d gkGVvzgi:>$/7CG\`vz$%vw9:33333333333333333333333333333333333333333 twNh!Nu n q m } drswsg7JCGX`vzCFGX\_`rvyz 2Fytf6i{6i{G 3 #,#7x#s%9x'N@[OY _x{B}00v}LZD\6&@4@ @@UnknownG.[x Times New Roman5Symbol3. .[x Arial9=  Consolas7..{$ CalibriC. Aptos Display3. AptosA$BCambria Math"q hIŲkɇ   *  *!nS203@P $P\2!xxk User;OE8<5B 940=0 Oh+'0\   $ 0<DLTUserNormal 3Microsoft Office Word@d@qaH@g   ՜.+,0 hp|  *      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:<=>?@ABCEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVXYZ[\]^`abcdefijmRoot Entry FZg lData ;1TableD$WordDocument 7tSummaryInformation(WDocumentSummaryInformation8_MsoDataStoreg g 0YZZG0I0R==2g g Item  PropertiesUCompObj r   F Microsoft Word 97-2003 MSWordDocWord.Document.89q